I was looking at the claimed "joined" date on the web server. It seemed "wrong" for Charm, claiming she joined 3/20/2011 but I have a sign I made for her first shop, which was a few days after she obtained her first cat (a female). The sign read "Tomcat needed" and the image was dated 3/10/2011.
While doing this bit of archeology I came across this image of her first cats morning the death of one of their number, image dated 3/28/2011. Blue Sorbet wasn't her first cat (the Flames on the right were). But it was her first support ticket and I remember she was near tears for two days waiting for the replacement.